A landmark appeal in a two-year-old ruling concerning education governance in our province is set to be heard this week. The original 2017 ruling in the case brought to court by the Good Spirit School Division stated that the Province of Saskatchewan would not provide Catholic school boards funding for non-Catholic students.

The case was brought about by the community of Theodore's efforts to save its school from closure. Theodore is located 40 kilometres northeast of Yorkton. In 2003, the Yorkdale School Division, the predecessor to the Good Spirit School Division, determined that the school in Theodore would face closure due to low enrollment with the students being bussed to Springside. However, Theodore school endeavoured to strike out as a faith identified school. The small multi-graded school, St. Theodore School, currently operates within the Christ the Teacher School Division which oversees Catholic schools in the Yorkton and Melville areas. 

The Yorkdale School Division launched the suit claiming that a Catholic school division should not receive government funding for non-Catholic students. That contention is maintained by the Good Spirit School Division which administers public schools in the region. In 2017, Justice Donald Layh agreed with the contention by stating the move to grant that funding to Catholic school boards was unconstitutional. The decision would have affected over 10,000 students in the province forcing them to attend public schools. The impact would have a profound effect in rural areas where shifting school populations in schools like St. Dominic and St. Augustine may result in serious funding and program implications. 

The 2017 decision was appealed by the Province. Now the hearing is set to begin on March 12 in the Saskatchewan Court of Appeal in Regina. Executive Director of the Saskatchewan Catholic School Boards Association, Tom Fortosky, explains the circumstance: "The Government of Saskatchewan has gone on record as saying they will use the 'notwithstanding clause' to basically check or overturn the decision on a go forward basis. So, there are no pressing implications at this stage."

The notwithstanding clause refers to Section 33 of the Charter which empowers provinces to override portions of the Charter in cases where broad public interests may be otherwise served. The Charter veto could be maintained for up to five years. However, beyond that, Fortowsky projects potential complications, "The implications down the road if the decision remains unchecked is that there would be some disruption certainly. Effectively, the case says that it's unconstitutional for the government to fund non-Catholic children who attend a Catholic School. What that would do is put a practical obstacle in the way of non-Catholic parents who would wish to choose Catholic education for their children."

Fortowsky notes that this scenario would have implications for both Catholic schools in Humboldt. As for Humboldt Collegiate, Fortosky outlines a different situation, "The high school itself is a public school with an agreement between the Catholic Division (Greater Saskatoon Catholic Schools) and the public division (Horizon School Division) for students who attend that school. It strikes me that as a public school, this case would not affect it."

The notwithstanding clause has not been proclaimed in force to date. If it is invoked, it would remain in effect for a period of five years. 

More Local News

Nominees and Winners from the 2019 Mark of Excellence Awards

The 2019 Mark of Excellence Awards took place on March 20th at Jubilee Hall. The yearly award gala is put on by the Humboldt and District Chamber of Commerce and recognizes business, organizations…

Saskatchewan Wildlife Federation Concerned By Environment Office Closures

The Saskatchewan Wildlife Federation has gone on record with its concerns about the impending closure of nineteen rural Ministry of Environment Offices. Humboldt is one of those offices slated for…

Saskatchewan's First Poet Laureate Visits Humboldt

A small but appreciative crowd gathered at the Reid-Thompson Library on Tuesday, March 19th to listen to one of the founders of the Saskatchewan poetry scene. Glen Sorestad has been writing for 50…

Work Under Way At 6th Ave.

City crews are currently working on a section of 6th Avenue at the corner of Main Street. Access to Main Street on the west side of 6th Avenue is blocked. Crews are working on a valve that provides…

Wildlife Federal Fish Fry Supports Club Ventures

On Friday, March 15th, the Humboldt Wildlife Federation hosted its annual Fish Fry and Awards Night at St. Augustine Parish Hall. The awards are designed to celebrate the year's accomplishment in…

Humboldt Steps Up, Shows Support for Stem Cell Swabbings

The Humboldt Broncos and Hockey Gives Blood joined forces once again and called on citizens to register for Stem Cell swabbings during Game 4 of the Broncos vs Bruins playoff series. The drive to…

Power Outages For Humboldt On March 20

SaskPower announces a pair of planned power outages for the city of Humboldt on March 20th. Residents are asked to be prepared for the following service disruptions: customers in the city of Humboldt…

Carlton Trail College Announces New Scholarships

On March 19th, Carlton Trail College announced a new series of scholarships totalling $25,000 in total value. These new entrance scholarships are to be disbursed as fifty individual scholarships of…

Fatal Collision in Wynyard

RCMP report a fatal collision occurred last night on Highway 16 in Wynyard. At approximately 8:30 pm, members from the Wynyard detachment, EMS and the local Fire Departments responded to an incident…

Music Festival Takes Over Humboldt

The Humboldt and District Music Festival will be gracing the city over the next couple weeks. Musician across all disciplines will compete in judged competitions in different locations across the…

DiscoverWestman.com is Westman's only source for community news and information such as weather and classifieds.

Search the Biz Guide

Login